User blog comment:SSWerty/The Swetty reviews/@comment-3097771-20110414090045/@comment-1668079-20110414091355

Because it still had its flaws. In the rare event that there's a 10/10, it has to be flawless, and I have to enjoy it.

A good example is this;

Someone writes a story. It's called X. I review X. I find no flaws with it, as it is perfect. Perfect in the sense that it has no conflicting errors, grammar defects, etc. But I didn't really enjoy the storyline.

It's like LOTR. It's an excellent novel. It is probably in my top three books of all time. But others don't like it. I don't know why, they don't know why, they just don't like it.

I loved Origins, and most of DD's work. But, they all have their flaws. Whether it's a mechanical flaw, or a flaw in the sense that I just didn't like it, there's a flaw.